Donald J. Pliner Black Suede Leather Boots/Booties,Solution to Address Competition, Innovation and Diversity: Implement a “luxury” competitive balance tax on bidding. The size of the “luxury” bidding tax should be imposed according to the total number of uncontested strings each portfolio Applicant has and the number of strings awarded to the same Applicant after contention resolution (e.g. after a private auction).
Adding the “luxury” tax would help incentivize partnerships. Also it would enable portfolio Applicants to prioritize and not overpay for some gTLDs and focus their attentions on those they would like to focus on which also facilitates innovation. By increasingly raising the luxury tax bid for each successive auction, ICANN will help level the playing field. There are many cases of other industries using efficient mechanisms to promote competition, diversity, and innovation, including: i) Salary cap and Luxury Tax Penalties, ii) Professional Sports Draft, and iii) Spectrum Caps:Oscar de la Renta Black Leather Boots/Booties,
(i) Pajar Black Designer Style Id: Foxtrot Farfetch Id: 123649 Boots/Booties,Salary cap and Competitive Balance Luxury Tax Penalties
In professional sports, a salary cap (or wage cap) is an agreement or rule that places a limit on the amount of money that a sporting club can spend on player salaries. The limit exists as a per-player limit or a total limit for the team’s roster, or both. Several sports leagues have implemented salary caps, both as a method of keeping overall costs down, and to ensure parity between teams so wealthy teams cannot entrench dominanceVicini Black Cutout Knee High Boots/Booties, by signing many more top players than their competitors.There are two main benefits derived from caps – promotion of parity between competitors and control of costs according to studies by:
Macalister Wedge (Nut Color) Boots/Booties,Dietl, H., Lang, M. and Rathke, A. (2009): “The Effect of Salary Caps in Professional Team Sports on Social Welfare”, The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy, Vol. 9, Article 17, http://www.isu.uzh.ch/static/ISU_WPS/72_ISU_full.pdf
Dietl, H., Franck, E., Lang, M. and Rathke, A. (2008): “Welfare Effects of Salary Caps in Sports Leagues with Win-Maximizing Clubs”, University of Zurich, ISU Working Paper Series No. 86, http://www.isu.uzh.ch/static/ISU_WPS/86_ISU_full.pdf
Brown Beana Fleece Lined Winter Ankle Barrel/Natural Displ Boots/Booties,Dietl, H., Lang, M. and Rathke, A. (2010): “The Combined Effect of Salary Restrictions and Revenue Sharing in Sports Leagues”, forthcoming in Economic Inquiry, http://www.isu.uzh.ch/static/ISU_WPS/102_ISU_full.pdf
For example, Major League Baseball implements a luxury tax (also called a competitive balance tax), an arrangement in which teams whose total payroll exceeds a certain figure (determined annually) are taxed on the excess amount in order to discourage large market teams from having a substantially higher payroll than the rest of the league. The tax is paid to the league, which then puts the money into its industry-growth fund (Dietl, H., Lang, M. and Werner, S. (2010): “The Effect of Luxury Taxes on Competitive Balance, Club Profits, and Social Welfare in Sports Leagues”, http://www.isu.uzh.ch/static/ISU_WPS/91_ISU_full.pdf).
PIKOLINOS Black New 'verona' Leather Ankle Boots/Booties,A team that goes over the luxury tax cap for the first time in a five-year period pays a penalty of 22.5% of the amount they were over the cap, second-time violators pay a 30% penalty, and teams that exceed the limit three or more times pay a 50% penalty from 2013 onwards. There is also an incentive to lower payroll; if in any year a team goes under the threshold, the penalty rate decreases to 17.5%, 25% or 40% (depending on prior record over the previous five years) for the next time the tax is paid, which will apply from 2013. The cap limit for 2011-2013 is $178 million, and for 2014-2016 $189 million.Primarily,Tory Burch Black Classic Rainboot Boots/Booties, caps prevent wealthy teams from certain destructive behaviors, such as signing a multitude of high-paid star players to prevent their competitors from accessing talented players and ensuring victory through superior economic power.Christian Louboutin Black Bello 100 Veau Velours Boots/Booties, With a cap, each team has nearly the same economic power to attract players, which contributes to parity by producing roughly equal playing talent in each team in the league, and in turn brings economic benefits, both to the league and to its individual teams.UEFA, the governing body of the Champions League, one the world’s most popular leagues in viewership, has implemented a policy called Financial Fair Play (FFP) to protect the game of soccer and level the playing field. The objective of FFP is to ensure that all sports teams can compete equally, to introduce more discipline and rationality in club football finances and to limit the ability of ultra-wealthy billionaire owners (such as Chelsea’s Roman Abramovich or Manchester City’s Sheikh Mansour) to subsidize team expenses. EU law and US anti-trust law are similar in relation to sports since courts:
(i) require evidence of an actual imbalance of competition in the marketplace,
Tory Burch Black Sidney Mid Heel Boots/Booties,Kenneth Cole Brown New York Justin Heeled Knee High Dress 546 Desert Boots/Booties,Valentino Black Rockstud 90mm Ankle Boots/Booties,Givenchy Black New Sz38 Shark-tooth Pant-leg Knee Boots/BootiesCharles by Charles David Black Knack Leather Boots/Booties,Melin (Shoes) Black Patent Leather Italian Ankle Boots/Booties,Black and Light Brown Vintage Pointed Toe Soft Leather Boots/Booties,Tory Burch Brown Knee Suede Boots/Booties,Corso Como Black New Munich Over The Knee Fashion Boots/Booties,Frye Black Suede Claude Tall Style Number 3475532 Boots/Booties,Pour La Victoire Black Women's Carrigan Buckle Ankle M Boots/BootiesStuart Weitzman Silver and Black Tones Boots/Booties,Giuseppe Zanotti Black Design Dalila Suede Fringe Boots/Booties,Sigerson Morrison Black Leather Vero Boots/Booties,Marc by Marc Jacobs Black Quilted Leather Boots/Booties,Fendi Black Zucca Print Knee High Boots/Booties,Sam Edelman Chocolate Suede Johanna Over The Knee Riding M Boots/Booties,Minnetonka Brown Child Suede Fringe Moccasin Ankle Boots/Booties,Tory Burch Black Ginger Shearling Lined Suede Winter Boots/Booties,Christian Louboutin Black Adox 85 Calf Leather Heel Short Ankle Stiletto Boots/Booties,Manolo Blahnik Black Patent Leather Boots/Booties,Modern Vintage Black Luxe Cuffed Leather Boots/BootiesBrown Leather Crocodile Boots/Booties,Burberry Prorsum Black Wingtip Wedge Boots/BootiesTory Burch Brown Chocolate Suede Wedge Boots/BootiesChristian Louboutin Black Lady Daf 37 It Platform Knee High Zip Heel Alti Red Sole Suede Boots/BootiesTory Burch Brown Christy Riding Boots/BootiesAlexander Wang Black Kori Tilt Heel Suede Boots/Booties,Brown Beana Fleece Lined Winter Ankle Barrel/Natural Displ Boots/Booties,Stuart Weitzman Brown Oxford Leather Boots/Booties,
(ii) allow sports teams to justify any competitive imbalances by demonstrating their legitimate pro-competitive benefits, and
(iii) to block sports teams from pursuing legitimate goals by overly restrictive means.It is clear that the FFP rules do affect “competitive balance.”
According to studies by the Institutue for Strategy and Business Economics at the University of Zurich (Egon Franck (2010), “Private Firm, Public Corporation or Member’s Association – Governance Structures in European Football”, International Journal of Sport Finance, 5(2), 108-127, http://www.isu.uzh.ch/static/ISU_WPS/106_ISU_full.pdf) other alternatives could also serve the purpose of leveling the playing field. One example is incorporating revenue-sharing, a common mechanism in professional U.S sports leagues. Another approach is imposing a salary cap based on the size of the league average payroll. Studies have shown that imposing a luxury tax increases competitive balance, especially if tax proceeds are distributed evenly between teams.By ensuring a healthy degree of parity between teams, games are more exciting for the fans and not a foregone conclusion. Sports leagues that have adopted caps because they believe letting richer teams accumulate talent affects the quality of the sporting product they want to sell. If only a handful of dominant teams are able to win consistently and challenge for the championship, many of the contests will be blowouts by the superior team, reducing the sport’s attractiveness for fans at the live events and viewers on television.Tory Burch Brown New Sullivan Leather Tall Boots/Booties,
(ii) Professional Sports’ Draft
Burberry Chestnut Brown House Check Detail Leather Riding Boots/Booties,ICANN’s Bylaws clearly highlight the need for implementing rules to foster competition, diversity and innovation and should follow in the footsteps of other popular and highly successful non-for profits such as the National Football League (NFL). ICANN is formally organized as a non-profit corporation “for charitable and public purposes” under the California Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation Law. ICANN was created in 1998 to oversee a number of Internet-related tasks previously performed directly on behalf of the U.S. government by other organizations, notably the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA). Before the establishment of ICANN, the United States controlled the Domain Name System (DNS) of the Internet.
Rag & Bone Black Mason Boots/Booties,ICANN could learn insightful lessons from non-for profits such as the NFL on how to make a League (or in ICANN’s case the DNS) highly successful in relation to competition as mandated by its Bylaws. The NFL has a remarkable track record: they are the most successful sports league in the world with nearly $10 billion of revenues in 2012. Furthermore, NFL teams are on average the most lucrative and highly valued sports teams in the world. The average worth of a NFL team is $1.17 billion while in contrast the world’s top 20 soccer teams have a mean value of $968 million.Rick Owens Black and White Trainer Boots/Booties,As a non-for profit organization the NFL implemented the NFL Draft to increase diversity, innovation and competition between NFL teams. In the NFL Draft, the draft order in the NFL is determined in a reverse-record order (the previous season’s worst team picking first, the Super Bowl winner picking last).Other leagues followed suit. In the AFL Draft, clubs receive picks based on the position in which they finish on the ladder. Therefore, the teams that finish at the bottom of the AFL ladder will get the first draft picks. Also, any team that finishes in a low ladder position for consecutive seasons will receive priority picks. The National Hockey League (NHL), another non-for profit organization, implemented the NHL Draft, which allowed all 14 teams that failed to qualify for the playoffs take part in a weighted lottery with the winner moving up as much as four draft positions and no drop more than one draft position.In the NBA Draft, instead of automatically granting the top pick to the worst team from the year before, the NBA holds a draft lottery to determine who chooses first. The top three picks are allocated by chance among the 14 teams that did not make the playoffs the year before. This discourages a team from losing on purpose to get a better draft pick.In the AFL Draft, clubs receive picks based on the position in which they finish on the ladder. Therefore, the teams that finish at the bottom of the AFL ladder will get the first draft picks. Also, any team that finishes in a low ladder position for consecutive seasons will receive priority picks.
Hunter Black Special Additional Heavy Duty Rain Boots/Booties,Isabel Marant Black/Blue Western Leather Suede Boots/Booties,Giuseppe Zanotti Black Sidney Leather Gold Heel Ankle 38 Boots/Booties,Tory Burch Black Elina 32087 Boots/Booties,Old Gringo Chocolate Brown Sweet Spice Boots/Booties,Old Gringo Brown Kemosabe Ladies Western Style L5983 In Box Boots/Booties,AllSaints Black Damisi Spitalfields Combat Boots/BootiesStuart Weitzman Black Napa Otk Boots/BootiesTory Burch Black Jaden Mid Calf Leather Buckle Boots/Booties,Frye Brown Gray Distressed Leather Regina Wedge 7.5) Boots/Booties,Tory Burch Dark Brown Bristol Riding Boots/BootiesHunter Black Tall Glossy Rain Boots/Booties,Tory Burch Black Simone Over The Knee 35mm Vintage Buffalo Boots/Booties Boots/Booties,Casadei Black Leather Pointed Toe Platform Ankle Boots/Booties,Manolo Blahnik Brown 9.5 Suede Pointed Toe Knee High Boots/Booties,Arche Rust Brown Suede Zip Up Ankle W/ Black Rubber Soles Boots/BootiesFrye Black Women's Melissa Button Boots/BootiesVia Spiga Black New Flory Wedge Knee High Boots/BootiesFrye Black Melissa Tab Knee High Boots/Booties,Valentino Black Floral Spring Garden Brocade Tall Boots/BootiesSteve Madden Brown Leather Spirit Boots/Booties,Fiorentini + Baker Light Brown Eli Star-studded Boots/Booties,Frye Black Patchwork Tall Claude Boots/Booties,Black / Gold Boots/Booties,Gianmarco Lorenzi Black Couture Platform Boots/Booties,Free People Soapstone Brown Fab Western Inspired Woven Venture Ankle New Khaki 7.5-8 Boots/BootiesJimmy Choo Brown Distressed Finch Leather Mid Calf Boots/Booties,Via Spiga Black Parca Knee High Leather High Heel Boots/BootiesBottega Veneta Black Smooth Leather Riding 36 Boots/BootiesValentino Black Spring Camu Garden Patchwork Brocade Knee Boots/Booties
According to the Kevin B. Grier, Robert D. Tollison, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, The rookie draft and competitive balance: The case of professional football, Vol. 25, 1994, http://faculty-staff.ou.edu/G/Kevin.B.Grier-1/JEBO1994.pdf:
Burberry Beige Black Red Creme Multicolor Nova Check Woven Canvas Knee-high Boots/Booties,On average, the draft clearly matters; higher draft choices raise winning percentages significantly over time. The rookie draft tends to promote competitive balance. Further, relative success in the draft is correlated with on-the-field success (pg. 298).
7 For All Mankind Brown Ego High Heel Zipper Boots/Booties,The draft tends to balance competition in professional football, as its architects intended it to do (pg.298).According to Ross Booth, Sport Management Review, Comparing Sports Leagues: Does a Salary Cap and Player Draft Measure Up?, 2005, 8, 119–143, http://law.psu.edu/_file/Sports%20Law%20Policy%20and%20Research%20Institute/booth%20comparing%20competitive%20balance.pdf:
Evidence of competitive balance in the AFL is consistent with Booth’s theoretical argument that the introduction of the team salary cap and player draft has improved competitive balance in the AFL (pg.120)